Editorial

Trimming Fat With a Bonesaw

Recently, Marco Pavia confirmed that TokyoPop has laid off 8 more people, including Hyun Joo Kim, who was instrumental in the World of Warcraft manga and hiring Korean talent to do world manga for T-Pop, as well as Bryce Coleman, the man in charge of color graphic novels.

Pavia claims that “It’s one of the worst selling periods in history,” and goes on to suggest that “[TokyoPop is] trying to be responsive to the new realities, and unfortunately some very talented people have been cut.” Downsizing is a popular business strategy when times get tough, but there’s a line you can’t cross as a business before you completely disable yourself. Trimming the fat is one thing, but it seems like TokyoPop is doing its trimming with a bonesaw. While other companies like Viz, DelRey, and Yen Press are staying active with releases, TokyoPop falls further and further behind.

I’m not sure I agree with T-Pop’s statement, although, for the record, I am not a manga publisher, so take my opinion with a grain of salt. I can’t really see the disposable income of single boys and men who are into manga disappearing because of a bad economy. Other manga publishers are being cautious, that’s true, but reports seem fairly optimistic about the fate of comics and graphic novels in 2009. But let me assure you, I can definitely see that demographic giving up on a series if they’re put through excessive wait times. How many people would keep up with the Naruto manga if it released twice a year (and let’s pretend it’s not being published in an anthology, because T-Pop doesn’t have one.) I couldn’t.

A thought in this slow down direction: perhaps TokyoPop’s manga printing slow down is causing this terrible selling period for them? I know slowing down your publishing rates seems like a good idea, but it’s possible that T-Pop is suffering from the backlash of angry fans; fans who believe their beloved series are dwindling into nothing. Fans who are afraid that they’re not going to get everything they want out of a series (most importantly is, of course, an ending.) Why should I pick up a new series from TokyoPop at this time? Their current business practices can’t confirm or promise an ending. For what it’s worth, T-Pop, here’s my advice; stick it out, but make yourself a gameplan and hold fast to it. Lower some salaries, stop these social networking shinanegans you’re trying, and publish some books. That’s what you do, right? Do it.
About these ads
Standard

2 thoughts on “Trimming Fat With a Bonesaw

  1. Pingback: MangaBlog » Blog Archive » News and reviews roundup

  2. Oliver says:

    Yes, I totally agree with you. This other media crap (like Princess Ai youtube vids) that T-pop’s investing in is frivolous. Their website is atrocious, but I’ve navigated pretty well through it to seek out some good titles I can find later at stores. I had to go through the website to get the names of series they cut, so that I wouldn’t fall victim to an unfinished story.

    The only way of avoiding heartache about not getting to know the ending of a series is to read series that are complete and printed, or ones that T-pop is sure of getting new volumes out. I’m sorry it is this way, but there are many outstanding series that deserved to be completed.

Comments are closed.